Please note that the laws conveyed are the views of the authorities cited in each post, but other authorities may disagree. Please check with your halachic authority.
All points of view are welcome in this forum, if expressed civilly. For personal manifestos, please start your own blog.
Wednesday, April 30, 2014
Entering in mid-kedushah
Hi,
One who enters the synagogue in the middle of Kedushah should respond appropriately to the lines he hears; he should not recite the parts that he missed.
Good morning, I wonder if, at some point, you would outline the acceptable range of responses of the tzibbur during Kedusha. Specifically, at some minyanmim, the tzibbur hums the melody along with the SH'Tz. In other minyanim, the tzibbur actually sings the WORDS along with the SH'Tz. Is this an acceptable halachic range? Or should we simply ask our local Rav? Michael Felder
Good morning, I wonder if, at some point, you would outline the acceptable range of responses of the tzibbur during Kedusha. Specifically, at some minyanmim, the tzibbur hums the melody along with the SH'Tz. In other minyanim, the tzibbur actually sings the WORDS along with the SH'Tz. Is this an acceptable halachic range? Or should we simply ask our local Rav? Michael Felder
ReplyDeleteMichael-
ReplyDeleteYou might take a look in Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim 125 and the Mishneh Berurah there; I think that might help.